Shelter Island’s Fav Deli + Mart | Stars & Stripes Mart
Logo

The All-American Spirit: A Guide to Whiskey

Written by Stars and Stripes Mart • October 22, 2025

2 minute read

Discover the all-American spirit with our guide to whiskey. Learn about bourbon, rye, and Tennessee whiskey—their history, flavor profiles, and what makes each style unique. From classic brands to craft distilleries, explore American whiskey traditions and find the perfect bottle for your home bar.
The All-American Spirit: A Guide to Whiskey

Born in the USA

Whiskey isn't just a drink—it's part of our national heritage. From the early distillers of Kentucky to the rye makers of Pennsylvania, American whiskey has been flowing through our history since the founding fathers raised their glasses. Today, whether you're sipping bourbon on the deck or pouring rye at the bar, you're participating in a tradition as American as the flag itself.

Bourbon: Kentucky's Liquid Gold

Bourbon is America's native spirit, and it's protected by law. To earn the name, it must be made in the USA, contain at least 51% corn, be aged in new charred oak barrels, and meet strict production standards. The result? That smooth, slightly sweet profile with notes of vanilla, caramel, and oak that's become synonymous with American craftsmanship. Whether you're a fan of classic brands that have been distilling for generations or newer craft operations pushing boundaries, bourbon delivers bold flavor and rich tradition in every pour. It's versatile too—sip it neat, on the rocks, or mix it into a proper Old Fashioned.

Rye: The Spicy Patriot

Before bourbon dominated the scene, rye whiskey was America's drink of choice. Made with at least 51% rye grain, this spirit brings a spicier, drier character to the glass with notes of pepper, fruit, and earth. Rye built the backbone of classic cocktails like the Manhattan and the Sazerac, and it's having a major comeback among those who appreciate a whiskey with more bite. If bourbon is smooth and sweet, rye is sharp and bold—a whiskey that doesn't ask for permission.

Tennessee Whiskey: Charcoal Filtered Excellence

Tennessee whiskey follows bourbon's rules but adds one extra step that sets it apart: the Lincoln County Process. This charcoal filtering mellows the spirit before barrel aging, creating an exceptionally smooth character. It's a distinctive style that's earned its place in American drinking culture, and it represents the pride and precision of Tennessee distilling traditions.

Stocking Your Home Bar

A well-stocked whiskey shelf should cover the basics. Keep a solid everyday bourbon for mixing and sipping, a bottle of rye for cocktails with backbone, and a premium option for special occasions or guests who appreciate the finer pours. Don't overlook smaller craft distilleries either—American whiskey makers are innovating while respecting tradition, and there are exceptional bottles being produced across the country.

Whiskey and the Water

There's something fitting about enjoying American whiskey by the harbor. Sailors have long appreciated a good dram, and whiskey has fueled countless toasts, celebrations, and quiet moments at anchor. Whether you're provisioning for a voyage or stocking the home bar, quality whiskey is always a smart addition to your supplies.
Stop by Stars and Stripes Mart and explore our whiskey selection. We carry the classics that built the category and the new releases keeping the tradition alive. From barrel to bottle to your glass—that's the American way.
Cheers and fair winds.