Shelter Island’s Fav Deli + Mart | Stars & Stripes Mart
Logo

Welcome to Stars and Stripes Mart

Written by Stars and Stripes Mart • October 22, 2025

2 minute read

Welcome to Stars and Stripes Mart—your neighborhood deli and liquor store offering fresh sandwiches, daily specials, and a full selection of beer, wine, and spirits. Quality food and drinks, all under one roof.
Welcome to Stars and Stripes Mart

Your Harbor Headquarters Has Arrived

We're honored to have you here. Whether you're a longtime member of the Shelter Island community, a sailor making port, or just discovering us for the first time, Stars and Stripes Mart is your patriotic provision station for quality food, premium spirits, and honest American service. We've built this place around the values that make this country great—hard work, quality products, and taking care of our neighbors. From sunrise to sunset, we're here to serve you with the excellence you deserve.

Fresh Deli Built on American Standards

Our deli counter runs on one principle: no shortcuts, no compromises. We stock fresh sandwiches, salads, and daily specials made with the same attention to detail that built this nation. Whether you're fueling up before a morning sail, grabbing lunch between watches, or picking up dinner for the crew at home, we've got you covered with honest food made right. From classic American subs to rotating specials that honor our culinary traditions, every item is prepared in-house with ingredients we're proud to serve. This isn't fast food—it's good food made fast, the way it should be.

Full Liquor Selection Flying Our Colors

Here's what sets us apart: we're stocked and ready with a complete selection of beer, wine, and spirits that would make any sailor proud. From Kentucky bourbon and California wines to craft beers and party essentials, our shelves carry America's finest drinking traditions alongside everyday favorites. Need provisions for a sunset cruise? Stocking up for a harbor celebration? Grabbing supplies before liberty call? You can get your sandwich and your six-pack in one strategic stop. No need to navigate inland when everything you need is right here at the water's edge, ready to load and go.

Proudly Serving Our Community

This establishment was built on a simple mission—serving this community with the respect and quality it deserves. We're here for the early morning coffee run, the midday lunch rush, and the last-minute weekend provisions. We know our regulars by name, we honor those who serve, and we welcome every new face through our door like family. This isn't some corporate chain where you're just a transaction. We're locally owned, locally operated, and genuinely committed to being the kind of place that makes you proud to shop local. Whether you need a quick recommendation, want to talk about the game, or just need to grab and go, we stand ready to serve.

Drop Anchor and Come Aboard

Whether you're here for a fresh sandwich or a bottle of American whiskey, we're glad you made port. This is your harbor headquarters, and we're just getting started. We've got big plans to keep growing, keep serving, and keep flying our colors high for this community. Stop in, introduce yourself, and let us show you what real American service looks like.
Welcome to the crew. Fair winds and following seas.